Ledger of Deeds
A hooded archer, in ink and watercolour, draws a bow into thick fog at dusk. No target is visible, and spent arrows stand in the grass.
All entries

Habitica review: it builds habits. Does it build skills?

Habitica is the best-known real life RPG, and it's free. It runs on repetition, and the research says that's how habits form. A skill needs something a tick can't give.

Compared5 min read

If you've looked for a way to run your life as an RPG, you've found Habitica. It's the best-known app of its kind, it's free, and its code is open source. I made Ledger of Deeds, so read this knowing that. Every fact about Habitica below comes from its own published text and code, linked at the bottom.

Habitica is very good at one thing, and the research backs it: getting you to repeat a behaviour until it sticks. That's how habits form. But getting better at something takes a different ingredient, and a tick can't supply it.

What Habitica is built to do

Habitica turns your to-do list into a game. You add Habits (things you do any number of times a day), Dailies (things on a schedule) and To Do's (one-offs). Ticking them off earns gold and experience. You level up, pick a class at level 10, hatch pets, buy gear and run quests with a party.

Missing a Daily costs health points. Run out and you lose a level, your gold and a piece of equipment. In a boss quest, your party's missed Dailies hurt you too, so everyone has a reason to keep up.

The whole game is free. A subscription ($5 a month up to $48 a year in Habitica's code) adds extras like monthly gear and gems you can buy with gold.

Every mechanic points the same way: show up, tick the box, come back tomorrow.

Habits are made of repetition

That's a sound design, because repetition is how habits form. In a study published in 2009, Phillippa Lally and her colleagues asked 96 volunteers to pick one eating, drinking or activity behaviour and do it daily in the same context ("after breakfast", say) for 12 weeks. Each day they recorded whether they'd done it and how automatic it felt.

Where the researchers could model it, automaticity rose along a curve that climbs and then levels off. How long it took to get near the top varied enormously, from 18 days to 254. And one finding matters for anyone designing a game around this: missing a single day did not materially affect the habit forming.

Habitica's tick-and-repeat loop fits that research well. Its penalties fit it less well. The study found a single slip didn't derail the habit, yet in Habitica a missed Daily costs HP, and enough of them cost a level. That's my reading, not the study's: Lally's team didn't test penalties. Some people want those stakes, and for them it works.

Skills are made of feedback

Now take something you want to get better at, not just do more often: writing, drawing, lifting, a language.

Repetition still matters, but it isn't enough. In their review "The Power of Feedback", John Hattie and Helen Timperley call feedback "one of the most powerful influences on learning and achievement", and add that its effect can be positive or negative depending on the kind of feedback and how it's given. Put simply, feedback is information about how the work went.

A tick carries none of that. It records that the session happened. It can't tell a hard training session from an easy one, or a page you're proud of from a paragraph you rushed.

Habitica does ask you one question about quality: how hard is this task? Its help text says difficulty describes how challenging a task is "for you", and you set it yourself. So you're the referee of your own work. That's the job psychology says we're worst at. David Dunning, Chip Heath and Jerry Suls reviewed the research on self-assessment across health, education and work and found that people's ratings of their own skill relate only "moderate to meager" to how they actually perform. Sometimes other people predict a person's results better than that person does.

Where Ledger of Deeds comes in

Ledger of Deeds is built for the skill side. You don't tick anything. You write what you did ("3 sets of 5 at 80 kg", "1,200 words of chapter four"), and on a plan you can add a photo of the work. The Judge reads it, weighs it against your own recent work in that pursuit, and gives a short verdict with the XP.

That verdict is the feedback a tick can't give, and it's measured against your record, not a difficulty you picked. In one real ledger, "Did legs at the gym" earned 14 XP. The same session logged in full, set by set, earned 53.

And there's no HP. Missing a day breaks your streak, but you keep every point you've earned, which is closer to what Lally's study found about a single slip.

It also does less than Habitica. There's no to-do list, no reminders and no party quests, and it costs money sooner: 10 free judgments, once, then $8 or $15 a month on the website.

Which one to pick

Ask what you're after.

If it's a habit, like vitamins, water, a daily walk or chores, you need repetition, and Habitica is a free, fun way to get it. Plenty of people will be happy there for years.

If it's a skill, you need to know whether the work is getting better, and a tick can't tell you. That's what the ledger is for.

Some people will use both: Habitica for the chores, the ledger for the craft. Either way, remember the difference: a habit needs repetition. A skill needs feedback.

Sources

More entries

Write what you did.

The Judge reads it and awards the XP. Your first 10 judgments are free.

Start for free